Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

  1. Cars and Engines
  2. Car Tech Talk
  3. Humans Drive Better in Twilight Than Automated Tech

Humans Drive Better in Twilight Than Automated Tech

30 Jun 2024
  • How do automated driver-assist systems compare to human drivers in handling collisions during sunrise or sunset and in complex cornering situations?

In the evolving landscape of automotive technology, the race towards fully autonomous vehicles has been both tantalizing and contentious. Recent findings published in Nature Communications have sparked a fresh wave of debate, suggesting that human drivers outperform automated systems in crucial scenarios, particularly during twilight and at intersections.

Comparative Analysis of Vehicle Collisions

Comparative Analysis of Vehicle Collisions

The study, based on an analysis of over 37,000 vehicle collisions, starkly contrasts human-driven vehicles' performance with those equipped with automated driver-assist systems. It reveals a striking statistic: vehicles utilizing automated technologies experienced five times as many crashes during sunrise or sunset compared to their human-operated counterparts. Moreover, in cornering situations, automated systems were involved in twice as many collisions, underscoring significant operational challenges during low-light conditions and complex maneuvers.

One of the primary challenges highlighted by the study lies in the limitations of current sensor and camera technologies employed by automated systems. These technologies often struggle to adapt swiftly to changing light conditions typical of twilight hours. Shadows and fluctuating light levels can confuse algorithms, potentially leading to critical misinterpretations—such as mistaking shadows for obstacles or failing to detect objects altogether.

The study delves into specific scenarios, such as intersections, where human drivers demonstrate superior situational awareness compared to automated systems. Unlike humans, whose perception extends beyond immediate surroundings, automated systems tend to focus narrowly on objects within close proximity. This tunnel vision approach can prove inadequate in dynamic environments like intersections, where anticipating and reacting to various potential hazards is crucial.

Furthermore, the study examines pre-collision behaviors, revealing distinct differences in driving patterns between human and automated control. Human drivers frequently exhibit proactive behaviors such as slowing down or changing lanes prior to potential collisions, whereas vehicles under automated control often maintain steady speeds until emergency maneuvers are initiated.

While driver-assist technologies have undoubtedly made strides in enhancing vehicle safety—particularly in preventing rear-end collisions and maintaining lane discipline—the study underscores that current automated systems remain fundamentally "assists" rather than substitutes for human drivers. They excel in predictable driving conditions but falter when confronted with the unpredictability and nuanced decision-making required in complex real-world scenarios.

As automotive technology continues to evolve, balancing the promise of automation with the demonstrated capabilities of human intuition and adaptability remains a pivotal challenge. The study serves as a poignant reminder that, while the future of autonomous driving holds immense potential, the road to fully autonomous vehicles must navigate through rigorous research, innovation, and refinement to ensure safety and reliability in all driving conditions.

Wael Nakhle

BY Wael Nakhle

Wael is an automotive content writer specializes in creating written content for Motor 283. Producing a wide range of content, including blog posts, articles, product descriptions, reviews, and technical guides related to cars, trucks, motorcycles, and other vehicles, with an unprecedented passion for cars, and motorcycles.

Road to Autonomous Driving: BMW First to Combine Level 2 and Level 3 Systems in the New BMW 7 Series

07 Jul 2024
Road to Autonomous Driving: BMW First to Combine Level 2 and Level 3 Systems in the New BMW 7 Series

BMW has made a groundbreaking leap in the field of autonomous driving by becoming the first car manufacturer to receive approval for integrating both Level 2 and Level 3 driving assistance systems in a single vehicle. The new BMW 7 Series marks this significant milestone, offering drivers an unparalleled blend of advanced technologies designed to enhance comfort and safety on the road.

The New Apple CarPlay Can Control Way More Than Before

18 Jun 2024
The New Apple CarPlay Can Control Way More Than Before

Apple enthusiasts and car tech aficionados alike have been eagerly anticipating the arrival of the next-generation Apple CarPlay, previewed by Apple back in 2022. The wait is nearly over as Apple has indicated that this enhanced system will drop later this year, though a specific timeframe has yet to be announced. The recent Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) provided an in-depth look at the updates, and the overarching theme can be summed up in one word: customization.

VIVATECH 2024 : PEUGEOT designs the future of driving pleasure with Hypersquare

18 May 2024
VIVATECH 2024 : PEUGEOT designs the future of driving pleasure with Hypersquare

PEUGEOT, a major player in technological innovation, electrifies VivaTech with its bold concept car INCEPTION, ushering in a new era of electric mobility. On its stand, PEUGEOT presents its vision of the future embodied by the revolutionary Hypersquare steering control– the innovation that redefines the driving experience of tomorrow.

ALLURE: The French public can discover the INCEPTION concept car for the first time.

EMOTION: The Hypersquare steering control radically transforms the driving experience and pleasure.

EXCELLENCE: PEUGEOT is a leader in technological innovation in Europe.

Building on over 200 years of innovation experience, PEUGEOT aims to reinvent the sustainable mobility of tomorrow by placing pleasure and emotion at the heart of the customer experience.